9/11 HERO Fraud! Alan Beaven - The Singing "Flight 93 Hero" hits a Bad Note

Phil Jayhan · 20 Aug 2010 , 00:51 AM

Alan Beaven - The Singing "Flight 93 Hero" hits a Low Note by; Phil Jayhan & The Surgeon

Alan Beaven - The Singing Flight 93 Hero

Whats interesting here is that this "sketch" was written by an alleged friend of Mr. Beaven. This one gets a wee bit deep as well; It is amazing the amount of sheer dishonesty and artistic license taken in this story of Alan Beaven. If you will recall, everyone who read these bio's or "sketches" as the NY Times called them wept, and then wept some more, and prayed for their families. They were made to identify the reader with what amounts to a fiction. While there is still much mystery and intrigue that surround Alan Beaven, we can be certain of one thing, and that his 9/11 story was a lie. It is already apparent that his "sketch" is a fictional account. Actually it is a web of not so carefully crafted lies interwoven together.

We will also see many more lies throughout this story, even when he received a "U.S. Senate Memoriam." Another word for NY Times "Sketch" would be a falsehood or lie. Because it appears that hardly any of the victims of 9/11, regardless of where they were alleged to have been killed, can stand up to any careful scrutiny.

Alan Beaven is listed in the Victims Compensation Fund, and the claimant is Kimberly Beaven. As a citizen of New Zealand, Alan would not be listed in the U.S. Social Security Death Index. (SSDI) And as such, did not perform an extensive search in SSDI, but there are no records of any Alan Beaven for all the obvious reasons, being an New Zealand national.

Quote:

Original link:

For Alan Beaven

Michael Edwards, 24 September 2001

Alan Beaven was a passenger on UA Flight 93. A friend pays tribute to a man who died the way he lived.

About the author

Michael Edwards is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at Demos: A Network for Ideas and Action, in New York, and the author of Small Change: Why Business Won't Save the World. He was formerly a director at the Ford Foundation. His website is www.futurepositive.org

“Fear - who cares?” reads a sign on Alan Beaven’s desk. Alan was my friend, and he died defending the same principles for which he lived: love, self-sacrifice, and the rule of law over the rule of violence.

Alan was a passenger on United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed in Pennsylvania on September 11th, just after 10 o’clock in the morning. Just before, two members of his family, separated by thousands of miles in California and Boston, had the exact same vision flash across their consciousness: Alan, with his arm around the throat of an unknown assailant, locked in a life-or-death struggle, and singing at the top of his lungs as the plane went down.

Now, of course, the world knows that this vision was reality. Alan and his fellow bravehearts overpowered their hijackers and forced flight 93 away from its intended target in Washington DC, sacrificing themselves in the process. His wife Kimi will be at the White House on Wednesday September 26th, to meet with President Bush.

Alan died the day after his eighth wedding anniversary, returning to California to prosecute his latest case against pollution in the South Fork of the American River. After a lifetime spent teaching and practicing public interest law in New Zealand, London, New York and San Francisco, Alan had risen to become the finest environmental lawyer on the West Coast. His specialty was the defense of the natural world against corporate interests, especially against the oil and logging companies. Although he did not win every case, the evidence he presented, and the arguments he made, have helped to strengthen corporate responsibility in the public eye.

Alan leaves behind a large and loving extended family, including John and Chris, his two sons by his first wife Liz, and the exquisite Dahlia Sonali, his 5-year old daughter by his second wife, Kimi Kaipaka Beaven.

“Where is Alan?” a friend asked Sonali last week, worried that she might not understand the reality of her father’s death.

“He’s in court”, she said, understanding perfectly well, “defending the angels.”

I love that, not just because it sums up Alan exactly, but also because it reminds us to hold onto the highest as we stumble forward in the weeks and months ahead. War, even death, would be no defeat for Bin Laden and his kind. This is what they want. Only the triumph of non-violence, secured through just laws justly applied, will bring the terrorists down.
Alan’s family and friends said goodbye to him yesterday, Sunday September 23rd. We swapped our favorite stories, sang to his memory, and saw photos of the heart of flowers, rice and sesame seeds that Sonali had made and left at the crash site, amid the hills and forests of Somerset County.

“Have I told you lately that I love you?
Have I told you there’s no one else above you?
Fill my heart with gladness, take away my sadness,
Ease my troubles, that’s what you do.”
Alan was a great soul, and he enriched the lives of everyone who knew him.

He was love in action.
Fearless, even in the darkest of circumstances.
And always on the side of the angels.
*****

Alan Beaven: October 15th 1952 - September 11th, 2001.

This article is copyright Michael Edwards and openDemocracy.

Whats fairly transparent here is the person making all of these claims about Alan Beaven was Director of the Ford Foundation which from my understanding is a Rockefeller Trust. [Citation needed]

Quote:

He was formerly a director at the Ford Foundation. His website is www.futurepositive.org

So far we have linked Obama directly to 9/11 through the fake victims, Carolyn Beug, and David H Rice. We have linked John McCain directly to 9/11 through his alleged relationship with Mark Bingham and McCain showing up at Binghams funeral. (Clinton and Kerry showed up at Sonia Morales Puopolos funeral) And we have now linked Alan Beaven back to an underling of Rockefeller, former Director of the Ford Foundation.

As we will see below from the Surgeons post, Alan Beaven has Exif/IPTC data issues. His Exif data reads 9/12/2001. hat's the last date and edit of this picture. But you will see below that CNN or AP Press having obtained these pictures at that early date is an awkward impossibility. See the story below that shows the first names released to the public wasn't until 9/12/2001 at 9:03 AM Western time. 1:03 PM Eastern. Remember when the Press gets a victims name, they don't get it with email addresses and phone numbers. They have to track those down. Then they have to email and/or call. This takes time. Alan Beaven's story is a grand work of fiction and just plain BS.

Quote:

Just before, two members of his family, separated by thousands of miles in California and Boston, had the exact same vision flash across their consciousness: Alan, with his arm around the throat of an unknown assailant, locked in a life-or-death struggle, and singing at the top of his lungs as the plane went down.

And a line or two later, this is subliminally embedded into the readers minds, unaware of the deception.

Quote:

Now, of course, the world knows that this vision was reality.

That above never happened except in the mind of someone trying to establish Alan Beavens false story.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Surgeon

According to a memoriam placed in the U.S. Congressional Record:

Flight 93 was completely destroyed into tiny pieces (according to the official story). How can his remained be found in the wreckage of the cockpit?

Anybody have info about the cockpit voice recorder?

http://www.janetdlaw.com/alanbeaven.html

Exif Data for Photo

Source: http://www.post-gazette.com/headline...eavenbiop8.asp

The taking a picture day is 13 September 2001 with title 'ATTACKS VICTIM". Interestingly, the Photograph number is CAOAK101. CA = California, OAK = Oakland (he was a long time resident of Oakland) and 101 = ???

AP Photo/courtesy of the law offices of Berman, DeValerio, Pease, Tabacco, Burt and Pucillo via Oakland Tribune. Alan Beaven worked for this law firm.

http://www.watertechonline.com/news.asp?N_ID=25564

Interestingly, the law firm has no tribute page for Alan Beaven.
http://www.bermanesq.com/

The Oakland Tribune -- Something Odd

United released the first names of the Flight 93 victims at 1:03 PM Eastern Standard Time, which is 9:03 AM California time.

http://www.united.com/press/detail/0...0454-1,00.html

Archived here, click spoiler below:

Spoiler:

The first article about Alan Beaven in the Oakland Tribune is dated 10 October 2001: "Flight 93 Hero's Wife Tells of Grief and Hope"

Use the archive search for the Tribune at: http://www.insidebayarea.com/archive-search using Beaven and a date range.

So, the Oakland Tribune obtains a photo of Alan Beaven on 13 September, but does not print anything about him for almost a month? A high profile lawyer?

CNN Memorial

His photo in the CNN memorial is missing.
http://edition.cnn.com/SPECIALS/2001...ople/1591.html

However, the above photo was originally in the CNN memorial. Using tineye.com, the site found the photo cached at CNN.

There really isn't any reason to continue here because there is already an abundance of data above to show the whole entire story is a work of fiction and a lie. Thus I rest my case.

We will however continue as time permits, follow other lines of investigation and compile more evidence showing Alan Beavens story to be nothing more then a falsehood.

9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud

Radio Shows - Jim Fetzer & The Real Deal:

Exif/I

PTC Metadata:

EXIF Data Similarities - VERY REVEALING INFORMATION

Video: Fraudulence on 9/11

Death Certificate #0001:

The Strange Story of Father Mychal Judge: Death Certificate # 0001 on 9/11

Social Security Death Payments & Other SSDI Related Evidence

Social Security Death Payments for 9/11 Victims

The Hollow Towers & Pre-Demolition of WTC:

Fireman Actors on 9/11:

Fireman Joe Casaliggi: Professional Actor - Also on 9/11?

Stand In Actors on 9/11:

9/11 Stand In Actors.

Flight 11 Frauds:

Flight 175 Frauds:

Flight 77 Frauds:

Flight 93 Frauds:

The 911 Jumper Frauds:

North Tower Frauds:

Pentagon Fraudulent Victims on 9/11:

Media Complicity and Fraud:

Media 9/11 Memorial Frauds:

The 9/11 Memorial Wall:

The 9/11 Victims Memorial Wall in New York City - Was it a Ruse?

9/11 & WTC Corporate Fraud:

Pending Research Requests from Lets Roll Members:

MISC: Great Research Links on this Material above:

Former Stickies for the Hussled Masses:

Pictures of Extra Equipment on Look-A-Like Flight 175 (109,720 Views)
911 For Dummies Thread. Video, Picture Archive of 911 (7,513,922 Views)
Targeting Laser Light Spot at the World Trade Center! (121,515 Views)
"Flight 175" WAS a Cargo/FUEL TANKER (159,126 Views)
New Photo of 767 Showing 2nd Piece of Equip / Port Engine (233,137 Views)
9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud, WTC Fraud

|

Phil Jayhan · 20 Aug 2010 , 01:06 AM

9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud

Radio Shows - Jim Fetzer & The Real Deal:

PART 1: Jim Fetzer, Phil Jayhan & Larry McWilliams on the Hollow Towers & Missing Contents of WTC
PART 2: Jim Fetzer, Larry McWilliams & Phil Jayhan - The Hollow Towers & Fake Victims of 911

Video: Fraudulence on 9/11

Sept Clues Video...

Death Certificate #0001:

The Strange Story of Father Mychal Judge: Death Certificate # 0001 on 9/11

The Hollow Towers & Pre-Demolition of WTC:

Flight 11 Frauds:

Flight 175 Frauds:

Flight 77 Frauds:

Flight 93 Frauds:

The 911 Jumper Frauds:

North Tower Frauds:

Media Complicity and Fraud:

Media 9/11 Memorial Frauds:

The 9/11 Memorial Wall:

The 9/11 Victims Memorial Wall in New York City - Was it a Ruse?

9/11 & WTC Corporate Fraud:

Pending Research Requests from Lets Roll Members:

MISC: Great Research Links on this Material above:

Former Stickies for the Hussled Masses:

Pictures of Extra Equipment on Look-A-Like Flight 175 (109,720 Views)
911 For Dummies Thread. Video, Picture Archive of 911 (7,513,922 Views)
Targeting Laser Light Spot at the World Trade Center! (121,515 Views)
"Flight 175" WAS a Cargo/FUEL TANKER (159,126 Views)
New Photo of 767 Showing 2nd Piece of Equip / Port Engine (233,137 Views)
9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud, WTC Fraud

|

**The Surgeon** · 20 Aug 2010 , 04:54 AM

Alan Beaven: Additional Information

FBI Report: 16762123-T7-B20-Flights-175-and-93-Load-Patterns-Fdr-Entire-Contents-FBI-Reports-222

Quote:

CLEA, DRUGX and NCIC were negative regarding Alan A. Beaven. TECS revealed 4 documented entries into the U.S.A. The following information was obtained from ChoicePoint, Lexis-Nexis and ACS:

PASSENGER Alan A. Beaven (Seat 17F)
ALIAS: Alan Anthony Beaven
DOB: 10/15/1952
SSAN: 074-70-7890
DR LIC: California = B3842238
ADDRESS: As of 07/00: [REDACTED]
SPOUSE: Kimberly Kaipaka Beaven
SSAN: [REDACTED]

MISC: 249A-SF-128129, serial 4 is a Pending Case opened 08/18/00 titled C and H Sugar Company, Inc. UNSUBS, DBA Environmental Crimes. Text reveals Alan A. Beaven is an attorney with the law firm of Herman, DeValerio, Pease & Tabacco, P.C., 425 California Street, Suite 2025, San Francisco, CA (415) 433-3200. Beaven and his law firm represent the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance and on 8/30/00 they filed a formal notice with C & H pursuant to Section 1365 of the Clean Water Act.

Entries into the USA

Alan had four documented entries into the USA. In 1992 he helped start a law firm in San Francisco. Considering his high profile career, I find it difficult that he had only four documented entries in the United States (see the first section of the FBI report).

I have been able to document three entries:

1) Move to Manhattan in 1985
2) Move to New York from London in about 1988
3) Return from India. Date unknown.

Something seems wrong about the number of entries into the USA - there should be more in the TECS (Treasury Enforcement Communication System).

Quote:

After a lifetime spent teaching and practicing public interest law in New Zealand, London, New York and San Francisco, Alan had risen to become the finest environmental lawyer on the West Coast.
http://www.opendemocracy.net/article/for-alan-beaven

Quote:

From the Congressional Record Memoriam

He taught law and practices in the areas of securities, class actions and environmental law in New Zealand, England, New York and California.

Quote:

From The History Channel – The Flight That Fought Back
Born in New Zealand, Beaven had a legal career that spanned four continents. In England he was a law professor at Kings College, a private defense attorney and a lead prosecutor for Scotland Yard. He practiced in Portugal, Hong Kong and New York before forming a firm in San Francisco.
http://dsc.discovery.com/convergence...orroll_01.html

Quote:

Senator Feinstein, U.S. Senate Honors Alan Beaven's Heroism with Congressional Record
<snip>
When John was 5, the family moved from London to New York and before they could drop off their luggage, young John made Alan play catch in Central Park. <snip>
http://thepebble.net/html/coastside_..._legacies.html

Son Chris was 18 in 2001, so this entry into the USA would be about 1988 when they moved to New York.

Quote:

<snip> Over the last decade, he had become heavily involved with Eastern philosophy, meditating, practicing yoga and spending a month in an ashram in India. <snip>
http://www.dailyamerican.com/article...ims/hero00.txt

Quote:

I did not know Alan Beaven perished on Flight 11 until I saw a segment on the Today show this morning, and they flashed Alan's picture. In 1986 Alan was an attorney at a firm in NYC that handled a wrongful death case my family filed on behalf of my brother, who had passed away in England.
Nancy Rudetsky Berman, Baltimore, Maryland
http://www.legacy.com/guestbook/guestbook.aspx?n=alan-beaven&pid=91569&page=16

Quote:

I worked together with Alan at Stamell, Tabaco & Schager in New York. Alan and his family are all wonderful people. Alan please know that you will be missed by many, many people. You are hero to us all. Thanks for everything you did up there. God Bless.
Terry Carigliano, New York, New York
http://www.legacy.com/guestbook/guestbook.aspx?n=alan-beaven&pid=91569&page=17

Social Security Number

Social Security Numbers starting with 074-70 were issued in New York state in 1985-86.

Alan’s SSN was issued when he was 33 – 34 years old (1985/6 – 1952). This means he obtained his social security number 2 – 3 years before he moved to New York. That is possible since one can obtain a SSN without living in the United States. He may have been working part-time for the law firm of Stamell, Tabaco & Schager in New York about this time.

Thanks to the website Decoding Social Security Numbers in One Step:
http://stevemorse.org/ssn/ssn.html

Social Security Death Index (SSDI)

Alan Beaven is not in the SSDI. Even though he was a New Zealander he was a member of the New York and California bar associations and practiced law. That meant he was earning an income and had to pay Social Security tax. His wife and daughter would be eligible for Social Security payments. Considering that he was a lawyer, I would expect his legal associates would counsel the family to take the money -- all they had to was register his death and apply for benefits.

http://letsrollforums.com/social-sec...084#post184084

Not Supposed to be on Flight 93

Quote:

Senator Feinstein, U.S. Senate Honors Alan Beaven's Heroism with Congressional Record
<snip>
Alan Beaven wasn't supposed to be on Flight 93 that tragic day. On Monday, September 10, Alan and his wife Kimberly were in New York planning for a year long sabbatical in India to work for a humanitarian foundation. Alan was a top environmental lawyer in San Francisco who planned to volunteer his services in India. Alan was headed east, not west, but there was one last case involving pollution in the American River near Sacramento and settlement talks had broken down that Monday. Alan had to head back. Tuesday morning Alan drove to Newark, New Jersey to catch a flight to the West Coast. Flight 93 was 40 minutes late that day <snip>
http://thepebble.net/html/coastside_..._legacies.html

Remains and Personal Effects Found in Cockpit

According to his wife in the television tribute (see below) his remains, wallet and wedding ring were found in the cockpit. The plane was shredded into tiny pieces.

There was NO cockpit.

Additional Information

Link to tribute for Alan Beaven from New Zealand TV n 2002. 15 minute video. RECOMMENDED.
http://tvnz.co.nz/content/2071201/2591764.html

Recollection of Former Law Partner Joseph Tabacco:
http://www.publiccounsel.org/news/2002/jan14022.htm

Quote:

A September 11 memorial will include childhood details of the only New Zealander killed in the attacks, thanks to a chance meeting between a Californian flight attendant and a group from Invercargill (New Zealand).
<snip>
United flight attendant Judy Jackson, whose colleagues died on the flight, is helping collect information for a memorial to be put up at the crash site in 2011, the 10th anniversary of the attacks.

She began researching Mr Beaven's history while accompanying her doctor husband to Invercargill, where he worked for six months at Southland Hospital.
<snip>
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/ar...ectid=10596580

Eulogy for Memorial Service Held for Alan Beaven in New Zealand:
http://waynemapp.co.nz/index.php?/ar...an-Beaven.html

Biography:
http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/ency...a/Alan_Beaven/

**F/O** · 20 Aug 2010 , 12:54 PM

I've been following some of this as time permits, and all I can say is unfu_king believable.

So these identities are what, pulled out of thin air? Who writes this stuff, stories about their identities and family members dreams and visions. These guys who write this sh_t are certainly accomplices in the crime of the century.

Carefully prepared alisas? How about carefully created fictional story identities.

Phil Jayhan · 20 Aug 2010 , 16:30 PM

Want to hear something funny Glen? I had never once heard Alan Beavens story, which is a story in itself. Had I ever heard this story or seen it on a youtube or whatever, I would probably have become suspicious of it when hearing it.

Quote:

Alan was a passenger on United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed in Pennsylvania on September 11th, just after 10 o’clock in the morning. Just before, two members of his family, separated by thousands of miles in California and Boston, had the exact same vision flash across their consciousness: Alan, with his arm around the throat of an unknown assailant, locked in a life-or-death struggle, and singing at the top of his lungs as the plane went down.

Only someone who is under their spell could hear this and not be suspicious. A spell is a lie. To be under their spell all one has to do is believe their lie. I am embarrassed that I never saw this before as we would have probably been where we are right now, years and years ago.

The singing Flight 93 hero. And his "families" visions of Alan in the Cockpit were proven to be true when they found Alan Beavens body in the remains of the cockpit. Talk about circular reasoning. What cockpit? What plane? What body? Alan Beavens body was never recovered, nor were any of the other 46 people allegedly aboard that 'fated fictional flight." (FFF)

This shows the fabric of their lie stretching across chosen people of the network that were going to "narrow cast" these lies in printed medium. Alan Beavens heroics, his bravado, and him being the "singing hero of flight 93" were never meant to be "broadcast" on network TV. The story is far too flimsy for this. It was rather chosen to be "narrow-casted" across pre-chosen printed mediums, in papers, magazines, NY Times, etc,...

Once one reads the words...

Just before, two members of his family, separated by thousands of miles in California and Boston, had the exact same vision flash across their consciousness: Alan, with his arm around the throat of an unknown assailant, locked in a life-or-death struggle, and singing at the top of his lungs as the plane went down.

One see's the lie immediately. This never happened. Add to this that they found Alan Beavens non existent body, in the non existent planes cockpit, after he performed a fictional heroic deed for a fictional plane full of people, and the story is over. Alan Beavens story is a total lie and a not so carefully crafted fictional story.

May Alan Beavens fictional story and fictional death on 9/11 R.I.P.

Cheers-
Phil

|

**do2read** · 20 Aug 2010 , 21:09 PM

Phil said:

Quote:

Want to hear something funny Glen? I had never once heard Alan Beavens story, which is a story in itself. Had I ever heard this story or seen it on a youtube or whatever, I would probably have become suspicious of it when hearing it.

I too was ignorant of the exploits of The Singing SuperHero.

This is some of the best, most thorough research yet.

He is the finest environmental lawyer on the West Coast and leaves almost no trail.

I have been often confused between Todd Beamer and Mark Bingham. Perhaps the alliteration is not by accident, as the prominent heroes are Beamer, Bingham, and Beaven. Perhaps part of the trick, to blend the thin backstories, so that the emotional aspects soak through without the logical consideration of the individual stories.

Similarities between the Beaven story and many others;

Impossible items found,

Premonitions by family,

Not supposed to fly,

Ultra-achiever,

Ghost like records left by important person.

This is a terrific example, and thanks for the fine research Phil and The Surgeon.

l

**AmberT** · 10 Sep 2010 , 11:11 AM

I can't believe what I'm reading right now. I went to school with Chris Beaven (3rd grade to 11th grade). I met his father Alan. He was a real person and was a REAL victim that died on 9/11. You are all sitting here claiming these people's family members were fake?! This is disgusting. I'm appalled.

**The Surgeon** · 10 Sep 2010 , 12:43 PM

Dear AmberT,

We are not saying that Alan Beaven is a fictitious person. What we are saying is that his EXIF date and IPCT data on his photograph was pre-dated to 9/11. That means he was set up to be a victim. That fact should be of great concern to you, since you are his friend.

I have been responsible for investigating Mr. Beaven's past and have found a great deal of evidence to support that he was a real person. However, something is very wrong with his story.

Please keep in mind that cell phone calls are not possible at the altitude and speed at which they were supposedly made on Flight 93. Also, there is no evidence that an airliner crashed in Shanksville, PA. Further, the crash pattern indicates a plane crashing at a 90 degree angle, while the official government story was it was upside down at a 45 degree angle.

We would welcome any additional information that you can provide concerning Mr. Beaven. His personal history is quite complicated since he lived in four countries and had a very active live.

Sincerely,
The Surgeon

**AmberT** · 10 Sep 2010 , 13:21 PM

I was pretty angry when I started reading the thread so I didn't read it all in detail. When I saw Phil Jayhan post:

Quote:

May Alan Beavens fictional story and fictional death on 9/11 R.I.P

That just really struck a nerve with me.

Chris and John lived with their mom Elizabeth in Carmichael, CA. Mrs. Beaven is what she went by, but I knew that her and Alan were not together. I'm not sure why she kept the last name. She was a teacher at our school: Sacramento Waldorf School. Very nice sweet lady. I liked her a lot. Chris' dad, Alan, came to most of our big ceremonies at Waldorf. I met him a few times, and always liked talking to him because he had a New Zealand accent. I thought it was so cool since I had never met anyone from there. He didn't live in Sacramento though, so he didn't have a strong presence there. He was always a nice guy, laid back, cool kiwi dude. I don't really have much information on him, you guys seem to know more than I ever did.

I see Chris usually once a year, when some of us from the class get together during the holidays to catch up. I've never talked to him about that day though. I always felt uncomfortable. I really didn't know what to say. I mean the day it happened, when I saw Alan's picture on the news, I was in shock. I talked to Liz on the phone and paid my respects. I sent Chris a letter but I never heard back regarding that. I didn't expect him to. My family donated money to them to help with funeral costs and what not.

I was just googling his name this morning to see if there was anything new people posted up. I always liked to read some of the nice articles about him. That's what lead me to this posting. Sorry I don't have much information.

Also my stepmom knew Mark Bingham, who was also on United 93.

I don't really understand why these people were meant to be victims. I do remember, back when this happened in 2001, a mutual friend of Chris and myself told me that Alan wasn't even supposed to be on that flight. That he changed his flight a day early to surprise his daughter and wife. I don't know if that was true or not though. Sometimes crazy stories get circulated around when things like this happen.

**The Surgeon** · 14 Aug 2011 , 09:11 AM

Flight 93 Hero Alan Beaven: Key Employment History “Facts” Fabricated or Questionable

Many of the “heroes” of the four flights have wholly or partially fabricated backgrounds: Mark Bingham, Todd Beamer, Ceecee Lyles, Barbara Olson, Barbara Arestegui and others. See various threads and posts in this forum for details.

A key employment history “fact” in Alan Beaven’s life is apparently fabricated: Lead Prosecutor at Scotland Yard.

Another employment history “fact” is questionable: Professor with King’s College London, Faculty of Laws.

Scotland Yard Lead Prosecutor: Complete fabrication

There are numerous reports and claims that Alan Beaven was a Scotland Yard Lead Prosecutor. These include numerous personal accounts, media articles and a U.S. Senate Congressional Record. I could find only one reference concerning the date of his supposed employment, which is 1980. Apparently, he became a barrister (i.e., lawyer) in England in 1980. See References at the end of this post.

An important reference is from Joseph J. Tabacco, Jr. -- his law partner in California at the time of his supposed death:

Quote:

A native of New Zealand, Beaven had a diverse legal career which included stints as a law professor at Kings College, London, England; a criminal defense attorney in private practice in England; a Lead Prosecutor at Scotland Yard in London; a private commercial practice in Lisbon, Portugal; as an Investment Representative in Hong Kong; and as a trial attorney with Lipsig & Partners in New York City.

SOURCE: Berman DeValerio Pease Tabacco Burt & Pucillo
CONTACT: Joseph J. Tabacco, Jr. of Berman DeValerio Pease Tabacco Burt & Pucillo, +1-415-433-3200, or jtabacco@bermanesq.com
Photo: NewsCom: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010912/NEW024
AP Archive: http://photoarchive.ap.org
PRN Photo Desk, +1-888-776-6555 or +1-212-782-2840
Web site: http://www.Bermanesq.com http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/WO0109/S00040.htm

A second reference is from his son John Beaven:

Quote:

Beaven [John] was determined to continue his baseball career, and he was back on the field immediately at the University of California-San Diego, dedicating the season to his father, a 48-year-old celebrated environmental lawyer who once was a lead prosecutor at Scotland Yard.

Source: http://www.sptimes.com/2002/06/23/ne...ospect_c.shtml

Alan Beaven was not a prosecutor with Scotland Yard (i.e., the Metropolitan Police Service of London – also known as the “Met”). Nor was he a prosecutor with the Crown Prosecution Service, which is responsible for prosecutions in England and Wales. I have obtained confirmed proof from a researcher that is working on the biographies of 9/11 heroes that repudiates these claims. I have reviewed all the original documents and correspondence and confirm they are genuine.

A FOIA request was made to Scotland Yard requesting confirmation that Mr. Beaven was a prosecutor with them.

Quote:

After making checks this prosecutor did not work for the Metropolitan Police and therefore he may have worked for the Crown Prosecution Service.

Reply from the FOIA department at Scotland Yard:

Scotland Yard transferred the FOIA request to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), which also replied in the negative.

Quote:

It is with regret that I confirm that I can find no information held by the CPS on Alan Beaven.

Reply from the FOIA department at the Crown Prosecution Service:

Note that King's College confirmed that Alan Beaven was employed with them from 1 October 1976 to 29 September 1981. His supposed position as Lead Prosecutor at Scotland Yard is reported as being in 1980. There is a discrepancy in these dates: he could not be Lead Prosecutor and be a Lecturer in 1980 at the same time.

Alan Beaven became an English barrister in 1980 and supposedly within the same year was hired by Scotland Yard as Lead Prosecutor at the age of 28? He was born 15 October 1952.

This is a serious fabrication in Alan Beaven's background. It is not clear if this fabrication was created by himself and/or by others. It is also not clear when this fabrication was initially created. However, it exists.

Professor at King’s College London, School of Law: Partial fabrication

The same researcher contacted King’s College Department of Human Resources and had numerous written correspondences and telephone discussions with department personnel, who were very helpful. Their reply:

Quote:

Apologies for the long delay on this. Both our HR and Payroll departments were not able to easily locate any information regarding Mr Beaven, as their systems did not go back as far as his time here. We did, therefore, request Mr Beaven’s file from the archives, and here are some details from the file:

Mr Alan Anthony Beaven
Date of Birth - 15 October 1952
LLB Bachelor of Laws (Honours) - 10 May 1974 - University of Auckland
Law Professional - 1974
Barrister and Solicitor of the Supreme Court of New Zealand - February 1975
Lecturer in Law (Constitutional and Administrative Law) at King's College London, Faculty of Laws (as it was known as then)
1 October 1976 to 29 September 1981
Left King's to go back to being a practicing barrister
Forwarding address was 12 South Square, Gray's Inn , London WC1

I hope this is helpful?

King’s College confirmed that Mr. Beaven was a Lecturer in Law (Constitutional and Administrative Law). Also, the HR department confirmed verbally by telephone to the researcher that several faculty remembered Mr. Beaven working at King’s College.

The key point is that Alan Beaven was a Lecturer and not a Professor. In academia, there is a major difference between the two positions; and, to claim the unearned title of Professor is highly unethical. Those knowledgeable about academia, and in particular, British academia will understand the gravity of a false claim to Professor.

Wikipedia has an excellent explanation of the difference:

Quote:

A lecturer in UK universities often holds a permanent position that involves carrying out both teaching and research. After a number of years, lecturers might be promoted to senior lecturers. This position is below reader and professor. In terms of responsibilities and recognition, the lecturer position is similar to assistant professor in the North American universities and international universities that are modeled on the US higher education system.

Traditionally, a senior lectureship was theoretically equivalent to a readership and demanded the same salary, but reflected prowess in teaching or administration rather than research, and was far less likely to lead directly to promotion to professor[1]. However, in recent years a senior lecturer has also had to demonstrate strong research prowess, as well as sound teaching and administrative skills. Senior lectureships are between lectureships and readerships in many universities and they will normally be promoted to readerships before reaching professorships. Senior lecturers and readers, however, remain on the same salary scale and in many departments still are comparatively senior staff.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lecturer

Note: The forwarding address provided to King’s College was Gray’s Inn, which is The Honourable Society of Gray’s Inn.
http://www.graysinn.info/

General References: Alan Beaven

Quote:

From The History Channel – The Flight That Fought Back
Born in New Zealand, Beaven had a legal career that spanned four continents. In England he was a law professor at Kings College, a private defense attorney and a lead prosecutor for Scotland Yard. He practiced in Portugal, Hong Kong and New York before forming a firm in San Francisco.

Source: http://dsc.discovery.com/convergence...orroll_01.html

U.S. Congressional Record – Alan Beaven: In Memoriam
http://www.gpoaccess.gov/serialset/c...pdf/senate.pdf
http://www.janetdlaw.com/alanbeaven.html

Life goes on for son of Kiwi who fought back on United Flight 93
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/ar...ectid=10400851

This reference correctly lists Alan Beaven’s position as Lecturer:
http://www.spoke.com/info/p6VNiaL/AlanBeaven

Kiwi Scientist Dies In Pennsylvania Plane Crash
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/WO0109/S00040.htm

Lisa Beamer’s book “Let’s Roll”
http://www.integritychristianstore.c...view&index=278

Alan A. Beaven, environmental lawyer, 48 was on airliner that crashed in Pennsylvania en route to San Francisco
http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/cgi/news/release?id=73326

United Flight 93 victims at a glance
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/...s-capsules.htm

Families, strangers remember Flight 93
http://postgazette.com/headlines/200...cene0923p5.asp

Alan Beaven
http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/ency...a/Alan_Beaven/

20 Aug 2010 , 12:54 PM	#4
F/O Moderator Join Date: 8 Apr 2005 Location: Indy Posts: 705 Threads: 54 Thanked 37 Times in 22 Posts	I've been following some of this as time permits, and all I can say is unfu_king believable. So these identities are what, pulled out of thin air? Who writes this stuff, stories about their identities and family members dreams and visions. These guys who write this sh_t are certainly accomplices in the crime of the century. Carefully prepared alisas? How about carefully created fictional story identities. __________________ UNCLE SAM'S CHRISTIAN PATRIOTS, a Personal, Political and Religious Discussion of September the 11th... by Glen Stanish http://www.tatepublishing.com/bookst...=1-5988625-1-0

10 Sep 2010 , 11:11 AM	#7
AmberT Reader Join Date: 10 Sep 2010 Posts: 2 Threads: 0 Thanked 5 Times in 2 Posts	Holy crap I can't believe what I'm reading right now. I went to school with Chris Beaven (3rd grade to 11th grade). I met his father Alan. He was a real person and was a REAL victim that died on 9/11. You are all sitting here claiming these people's family members were fake?! This is disgusting. I'm appalled.

10 Sep 2010 , 12:43 PM	#8
The Surgeon Moderator Join Date: 8 Sep 2004 Location: The Cancer Ward Posts: 1,291 Threads: 165 Thanked 1,669 Times in 464 Posts	Dear AmberT, We are not saying that Alan Beaven is a fictitious person. What we are saying is that his EXIF date and IPCT data on his photograph was pre-dated to 9/11. That means he was set up to be a victim. That fact should be of great concern to you, since you are his friend. I have been responsible for investigating Mr. Beaven's past and have found a great deal of evidence to support that he was a real person. However, something is very wrong with his story. Please keep in mind that cell phone calls are not possible at the altitude and speed at which they were supposedly made on Flight 93. Also, there is no evidence that an airliner crashed in Shanksville, PA. Further, the crash pattern indicates a plane crashing at a 90 degree angle, while the official government story was it was upside down at a 45 degree angle. We would welcome any additional information that you can provide concerning Mr. Beaven. His personal history is quite complicated since he lived in four countries and had a very active live. Sincerely, The Surgeon __________________ "...it does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority to set bush fires in people's minds" Samuel Adams