Fl# 93: Mark Bingham - 9/11 "Lets Roll" HERO Proven a Fraud!

Phil Jayhan · 6 Aug 2010 , 19:47 PM

Mark Bingham - Exif/IPTC Data 8/30/2001! 13 Days before 9/11!

Mark Bingham was sold and told to us to be one of the heros of September 11th. The U.S. State Run media told us so. Later the U.S. Congress would also say the same by making an official Memoriam for Alan Beaven. Mr. Bingham was one of those who gathered both their wit and their courage, and allied with several other bravado's from Flight 93, stormed the hijackers and the cockpit, ejecting the hijackers, and saving what we were told was the intended target, the U.S. Capitol Building in Washington D.C. They successfully foiled the plan on this one flight, but in doing so, sacrificed their own lives. They died unbeaten, unbroken. They went down in flames. This band of brothers died as Hero's of the first class. True blue to the core.

There is a problem however. All of it is was a lie. None of it ever happened.

There is a rather large blunder on the part of CNN & the AP Press; Mark Binghams Exif/IPTC data shows as 8/30/2001. Some 13 days before 9/11, complete with a working bio and obituary, all carefully prepared, or in this case, not so carefully prepared some two weeks before 9/11! It is no wonder that CNN went removing so many hundreds of pictures from their CNN Memorial page, only weeks after breaking the Mike Rivero/John Wenckus story. Mark Binghams picture being one of them.

There are some major issues and incriminating evidence in the digital IPTC data. And it is damning. Does anyone here think that it is a coincidence that Mark Binghams picture was removed from the CNN Memorial archive, especially when we now know that the picture was prepared weeks before 911 chock full with an obituary & has this information openly available in the Exif data? The original picture of Mark Bingham showing the exif data of 8.30.01 can still be viewed at the Web Archive:

The picture being taken day, from our understanding is overwritten when the picture is edited, as in this case, with the white side bard which says Family Photo/AP Press and also the obituary which is embedded into the digital coding of the picture. For that picture being taken day to be anything before 9/11 is extremely damning, as long as the picture is like the one above, edited, with an obituary.

When someone edits the picture, the IPTC data is overwritten and the picture being taken day is changed to the day of the last edit. Since this picture is allegedly from his 1993 graduation, 8.30.2001 cannot be anything other then when the picture was last edited and prepared for it's 9/11 release. Before 9/11!

Mark Bingham was one of the "Lets Roll Hero's"

Mark Bingham was scripted with being one of the hero's on 9/11. For whatever reason. My own guess is that the people who were allowed to play the role of hero's were well connected individuals. Mark Bingham is the person who allegedly made a cell phone call to his Mother from Flight 93 and told her; "This is Mark Bingham Mom, your son,. You believe me right.." [From memory - citation needed] We were told he, Todd Beamer and a few others then rushed the arab hijackers and crashed the plane.

Perhaps someone should email these people and inform them someone just took out one of their hero's. The Exif/IPTC data inside the picture shows simply that the picture was created and prepared just prior to 9/11. The implications are enormous, and simple to see and understand.

Mark Binghams CNN Memorial Page - Web Archive

Name: Mark K. Bingham

Age:31

Residence: San Francisco, CA, United States

Occupation: owner, The Bingham Group

Location:

UA Flight 93

Related: Legacy.com tribute

Updated:January 2, 2002

Mark Bingham - Legacy page

United Flight 93

Mark Bingham, 31,

of San Francisco,

owner of The Bingham Group, a public relations firm.

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

Notice how it says how he was killed, 13 days before 9/11? Just who is Mark Bingham anyway? We were told that he was an openly gay man. President of his fraternity. And told that he nearly missed his flight, Flight 93. We were told the plane actually had closed its door and then reopened it to allow him to board.

Yet we know now that Flight 93 never happened. That Mark Bingham never showed at the airport, nor did any of the other 246 passengers and crew. FYI - We were also informed quietly via the FBI that the Flight 93 drama never occurred. This came out in trial of one of the alleged hijackers;

9/11 Flight 93 Passenger Uprising Theory Discounted - LA Times

Yet Mark Bingham was scripted with being one of the hero's. Was he already dead before 9/11? Did he ever really exist? If so, is he still alive? While we have this extremely damning evidence which is even better then an actual smoking gun, it should still be noted that there is still a mystery here as to just who Mark Bingham was. Yet this answers in a very direct way, peoples questions as to what happened to the passengers. They were created fictions, and various other categories of prepared aliases.

See Larry's article on the different categories of 'carefully prepared aliases.'

To think that this information was hidden inside all these pictures all these years without anyone noticing. Information which effectively tells us that the pictures were frauds, and made beforehand, complete with obituary and bio!

Just to point out the high caliber proof this represents, ask yourself; Would you rather take your time showing somebody that cell phone calls cannot be made from commercial aircraft, or would you rather simply show them how the pictures of the alleged victims and victim hero's were created before 9/11?

Mark Bingham is not in the Social Security Death Index nor is he in the Victims Compensation Fund: Why not?

Name Birth Death Age Last Address of Record Last Benefit Issued By SSN ToolsOrder Record?

BINGHAM, MARK 28 Jan 1951 May 1981 30 (not specified) 02664 (South Yarmouth, Barnstable, MA) Massachusetts 025-42-9353

BINGHAM, MARK 06 Nov 1954 15 Aug 1994 3919154 (Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA) (none specified)Pennsylvania182-48-1642

BINGHAM, MARK O12 Jun 1966 12 Jun 2000 (P)34(72)(none specified) Idaho 518-98-0345

BINGHAM, MARK 30 Dec 1964 24 Aug 1996 (V)3177045 (Houston, Harris, TX )(none specified) Colorado524-31-6549

Exif/IPTC Digital Data hangs them!

This leaves no doubt as to whether or not the pictures and alleged victims were carefully prepared aliases. Mark Binghams picture was in someones file and prepared and ready to use some 13 days before 9/11. Sonia Morales Puopolos Exif/IPTC digital data reads April 3rd, 2001, some 6 months or more before 9/11! And there is little doubt in my mind that this is the very reason why CNN was pulling hundreds of pictures off their CNN Memorial pages after breaking the story about Mike Rivero possibly being John Wenckus.

So apparently we struck a nerve at CNN and someone with a sharp eye went through the pictures and removed all the obvious pictures with obvious exif/IPTC digital data issues.

Imagine spending 10 Billion dollars and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of man hours on pulling off 9/11, and then to have the entire operation be proven false because someone out there took a single memorial picture and ran it through a free exif data viewer! They had us where they wanted us. Arguing about what 911 evidence is best and whats crap and keeping us hopelessly divided all along. But I think these new discoveries, by their mere preponderance, will change everything in the 9/11 landscape.

When we see his mother and stepfather giving testimony about the days events on 9/11 and their alleged son Mark Bingham, their story isn't very believable at all.

YouTube- ‪Mark Bingham's Mom‬&lrm;

YouTube- ‪Alice Hoglan, mother Mark Bingham, ABC, 17:55, 9/12‬&lrm;

YouTube- ‪CNN Alice Hoglan laughs about sons call‬&lrm;

9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud

Radio Shows - Jim Fetzer & The Real Deal:

9/11 World Trade Center Props

World Trade Center Publicity Stunts:

What does Phillipe Petit know about the hollow WTC towers?

Exif/IPTC Metadata:

EXIF Data Similarities - VERY REVEALING INFORMATION

Video: Fraudulence on 9/11

Death Certificate #0001:

Social Security Death Payments & Other SSDI Related Evidence

Social Security Death Payments for 9/11 Victims

The Hollow Towers & Pre-Demolition of WTC:

The World Trade Center Lighting & Picture History

The Elevators at WTC on 9/11 and the Trapped People:

Outrageous WTC 9/11 elevator stories exposed

Revisiting the World Trade Center Phone Calls:

Revisiting the WTC 911 calls

Fireman Actors on 9/11:

Stand In Actors on 9/11:

Flight 11 Frauds:

Flight 175 Frauds:

Triplets Separated at Birth - Edward H. Luckett, Carlton Bartels, Michael Tarrou

Flight 77 Frauds:

Flight 93 Frauds:

The 911 Jumper Frauds:

North Tower Frauds:

Pentagon Stage Props - Pentagon TV Fakery:

Pentagon Fraudulent Victims on 9/11:

Media Complicity and Fraud:

Media 9/11 Memorial Frauds:

The 9/11 Memorial Wall:

The 9/11 Victims Memorial Wall in New York City - Was it a Ruse?

9/11 & WTC Corporate Fraud:

Gatekeepers of the Alternate Media:

Jason Burmas On Fake 9/11 Victims (gatekeeper)!

Pending Research Requests from Lets Roll Members:

MISC: Great Research Links on this Material above:

Former Stickies for the Hussled Masses:

Pictures of Extra Equipment on Look-A-Like Flight 175 (109,720 Views)
911 For Dummies Thread. Video, Picture Archive of 911 (7,513,922 Views)
Targeting Laser Light Spot at the World Trade Center! (121,515 Views)
"Flight 175" WAS a Cargo/FUEL TANKER (159,126 Views)
New Photo of 767 Showing 2nd Piece of Equip / Port Engine (233,137 Views)
9/11 LINKS INDEX - Victim Fraud, Media Fraud, WTC Fraud

Former Stickies for Pentagon Forum:

|

Bushbasher49 · 6 Aug 2010 , 20:41 PM

is this a grieving mom that just lost her son NO shes smiling and lauging all the why through the video what a fraud and a scam

~~VonZolta~~ · 6 Aug 2010 , 20:43 PM

This post is dead

**Jon Simon** · 6 Aug 2010 , 20:59 PM

That's pretty damning evidence, Phil. Seems there be spooks (intelligence agency assets) in the woodpile at CNN and/or AP.

I've always had a huge question mark filed on the Mark Bingham aspect of 9/11. No one I know would call their mom and say, "Mom...this is Mark Bingham." The whole story about taking back the plane with "Let's Roll!" also stunk to high heaven to me.

So who is the woman who says she's his mom and she received the call? Seems some very serious and pointed questions need to be directed her way.

Jon

**Jon Simon** · 6 Aug 2010 , 21:30 PM

Another interesting thing to do would be to find out the names of the people who worked at CNN or AP the month before 9/11 who's job it was to edit those photos. Who worked in the graphics or editting department.

--->There will be our spooks.<---

Jon

**do2read** · 6 Aug 2010 , 23:03 PM

Great article Phil!

Most of us knew about the most ridiculous of all of the phone calls, and the odd behavior of Alice Hoglan and her Husband, But the Exif/IPTC data puts those observations in a whole new light.

Instead of being two of 911's little oddities, now they are solid legs under a story which was put together well before 911.

The words of the phone call were never expected to be held under scrutiny. They were meant to slide easily into our subconscious, especially the "you do believe me, don't you" part. It was to register in our brains as a 911 hero asking us directly to "believe him". At a time of emotional shock (which was a spell the whole world was under) these suggestions are VERY powerful.

Held to scrutiny, outside the "spell", they are obviously not genuine comments.

Mrs. Hoglan appears more like a nervous actress than a grieving mother. I believe now we can conclude that is because she was a nervous actress, not a grieving mother.

I think one thing Phil has clearly shown is a correlation between the:
a. earlier Exif/IPTC data
b. flawed, overdone human interest stories
c. families thrust in the limelight right in the wake of 911.

From Tania Head, to Sonia Puopolo and from George Sleigh to Ruth McCourt and Paige Hackel, wherever you have a survivor or family in the limelight, we have found a seriously flawed story behind them.

It is becoming obvious now that there were Actors, well (?) prepared BEFORE 911, to make the talk show "rounds", to reinforce for us the existence of their "dear departeds".

Out of the reported 2800 deaths, we seem to see only the same handful of "families" in the media.

Out of 20,000+ reported survivors, we see only a handful making media appearances.

Phil, you've settled the story of 911 Hero Mark Bingham once and for all.

LetsRoll!

l

Phil Jayhan · 6 Aug 2010 , 23:29 PM

I just found this while searching google. Ironically it was from the lets roll forums!

Some very good research here that ties Bingham and Beamer together outside of flight 93.

Cheers-
Phil

Original link:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mountain_Lion_42

According to the official story of the 9/11/2001 terrorist attacks, Todd Beamer and Mark Bingham fought terrorists on United Airlines Flight 93 and forced that plane to crash in Pennsylvania.

However, I have discovered that United 93 is not the only connection between Beamer and Bingham.

First of all, Beamer and Bingham went to high school together. Specifically, they attended Los Gatos High School in Los Gatos, a town in northern California.

Mark Bingham attended Los Gatos High School for 4 years, from 1984 to 1988. [1]

Todd Beamer attended Los Gatos High School during the 1986-1987 school year, which was his senior year. [2]

So, for 1 year, Beamer and Bingham went to high school together.

Todd Beamer and Mark Bingham are also connected via the business world.

Specifically, they are both connected to a man named Eric Benhamou.

Mark Bingham graduated from college in 1993, and his own company opened for business in 1999. For some period of time between the 1993 graduation and the 1999 opening, Bingham worked for 3Com Corporation. [3]

The CEO of 3Com from September 1990 to December 31, 2000, was Eric Benhamou. [4]

Thus, Benhamou was the CEO during Mark Bingham's employment at 3Com.

Now, did Benhamou and Bingham know each other personally? Well, if you look at the news database Factiva (available at public libraries), you will find two 3Com press releases, one from September 2, 1999, and the other from October 11, 1999. These press releases appeared in the publication known as Business Wire. If you look at the bottom of each press release, you will see Mark Bingham's name and phone number listed in the "contact" section. So, Bingham was a press secretary for 3Com, just as Tony Snow was the press secretary of the White House. So, just as we are sure that Tony Snow personally knew the people in charge of the White House (Bush, Cheney, etc.), we can be sure that Bingham personally knew Benhamou.

In addition to working for 3Com, Mr. Benhamou was a member of the Board of Directors of the company known as Legato Systems.

Benhamou was appointed to Legato's Board of Directors in 1993. [5]

Benhamou was on Legato's Board as late as September 2001. [6]

David Beamer, Todd Beamer's father, was appointed Legato Systems's executive vice president of worldwide sales in January 2001. [7]

David Beamer was appointed chief operating officer (COO) of Legato Systems in February 2002. [8]

Thus, David Beamer and Eric Benhamou worked at Legato at the same time for at least 9 months (from January 2001 to September 2001).

Furthermore, during those 9 months, Benhamou had the high rank of member of the Board of Directors, and David Beamer had the high rank of executive vice president of worldwide sales. Thus, it is very probable that Eric Benhamou and David Beamer knew each other personally.

So, Eric Benhamou worked with Mark Bingham and with David Beamer, Todd's father.

Also, Mr. Benhamou has many ties to Israel. [9]

There is another passenger from United Airlines Flight 93 that should be noted, and that is Nicole Miller. At the time of 9/11, Nicole was a student at West Valley College in northern California. Alice Hoglan, Mark Bingham's mother, was also a student at West Valley College at the time of 9/11. [10]

So, Todd Beamer has ties to Mark Bingham, and Mark Bingham has ties to Nicole Miller.

[1]
Source: http://www.svcn.com/archives/lgwt/09...ver1-0138.html

[2]
Source: http://www.svcn.com/archives/lgwt/09...ver2-0138.html

[3]
Source: 1/22/2002 article in the magazine The Advocate
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articl...22/ai_81790790

[4]
Source: Benhamou's biography on the 3Com website
http://www.3com.com/corpinfo/en_US/i.../benhamou.html

[5]
Source: June 1993 issue of Software Magazine
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articl...13/ai_13922367

[6]
Source: 9/24/2001 article in the publication Business Wire
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articl...24/ai_78549452

[7]
Source: January 8, 2001, article in the publication Business Wire
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articl..._8/ai_68883629

[8]
Source: February 28, 2002, article in the publication Business Wire
http://www.findarticles.com/p/articl...28/ai_83357513

[9]
Source: Benhamou's biography on the 3Com website
http://www.3com.com/corpinfo/en_US/i.../benhamou.html

[10]
Source: http://www.svcn.com/archives/lgwt/09...over-0139.html

|

brian smith · 7 Aug 2010 , 00:36 AM

The whole flight 93 story always seemed like a contrived fiction anyway. They even made sure to give us a catchy slogan ("Let's roll") designed to whip us up into war mode. Let's roll? Give me a freakin break.

I have always thought the alleged mother, Alice Hoglan was being less than truthful also. What mother grins and chuckles the very day after her son is tragically killed by terrorists???

Very interesting findings here Phil. No doubt about that.

dutchtreat · 7 Aug 2010 , 03:42 AM

Hi Phil,

excellent research imo and now the net closes because besides the fake cellphone calls from fl 93 now also the false identity is exposed concerning flight 93.

the pentagon has already been exposed thru a/ the impossible flight turn before the crash and b/ the funny crash area (reinforced and hardly any people there)

the twin towers also have been exposed by you (asbestos, empty and gutted floors etc)

hardly any relatives (no one questioned on that day by reporters) on la airport after the twin tower crashes

the many many investigations of scams hidden in wtc 7 and "unfortunately" the loss of it when wtc7 went down.

the 4 events happened as we know now to start a war to protect oil interest under a false flag.

many questions about what happend are solved by this forum.

if the existence of Betty Ong in NY can be explained (versus the no passenger theory) than the circle to me is round and then the following question is becoming important :

the big question remains : who is the originator or architect of this all ?

greetz

Ben

**Rings of Saturn** · 7 Aug 2010 , 15:15 PM

Good work...good lord this is huge...

Is there anything on Todd Beamer...???

I will not assume that CNN or the AP is in on the job....so, is there anyway of knowing who create those files, loaded them or where they came from. This is now how many different EXIF info dates that are off...from how many sources?

Can we assume that someone at the Pent or DOD-- govt agency, gave the media these files for their memorials? This probbaly came from way up....trickled down the line and was eventually fed to us.

6 Aug 2010 , 20:43 PM	#3
~~VonZolta~~ Join Date: 14 Jun 2010 Location: Defender of the Faith Posts: 525 Threads: 8 Thanked 733 Times in 323 Posts	Bingham Citation - J Fetzer This post is dead Last edited by VonZolta; 18 Oct 2010 at 15:04 PM. Reason: Edited for paragraph bleed; formatting - VZ added piece of info

6 Aug 2010 , 23:03 PM	#6
do2read Moderator Join Date: 26 Jan 2005 Posts: 1,912 Threads: 92 Thanked 4,769 Times in 1,315 Posts	Great article Phil! Most of us knew about the most ridiculous of all of the phone calls, and the odd behavior of Alice Hoglan and her Husband, But the Exif/IPTC data puts those observations in a whole new light. Instead of being two of 911's little oddities, now they are solid legs under a story which was put together well before 911. The words of the phone call were never expected to be held under scrutiny. They were meant to slide easily into our subconscious, especially the "you do believe me, don't you" part. It was to register in our brains as a 911 hero asking us directly to "believe him". At a time of emotional shock (which was a spell the whole world was under) these suggestions are VERY powerful. Held to scrutiny, outside the "spell", they are obviously not genuine comments. Mrs. Hoglan appears more like a nervous actress than a grieving mother. I believe now we can conclude that is because she was a nervous actress, not a grieving mother. I think one thing Phil has clearly shown is a correlation between the: a. earlier Exif/IPTC data b. flawed, overdone human interest stories c. families thrust in the limelight right in the wake of 911. From Tania Head, to Sonia Puopolo and from George Sleigh to Ruth McCourt and Paige Hackel, wherever you have a survivor or family in the limelight, we have found a seriously flawed story behind them. It is becoming obvious now that there were Actors, well (?) prepared BEFORE 911, to make the talk show "rounds", to reinforce for us the existence of their "dear departeds". Out of the reported 2800 deaths, we seem to see only the same handful of "families" in the media. Out of 20,000+ reported survivors, we see only a handful making media appearances. Phil, you've settled the story of 911 Hero Mark Bingham once and for all. LetsRoll! l __________________ "Don't worry about it - Americans don't read." Allan Dulles ...

7 Aug 2010 , 00:36 AM	#8
brian smith Privileged Join Date: 9 Jan 2006 Location: Titan crater, Moon Posts: 200 Threads: 14 Thanked 463 Times in 155 Posts	The whole flight 93 story always seemed like a contrived fiction anyway. They even made sure to give us a catchy slogan ("Let's roll") designed to whip us up into war mode. Let's roll? Give me a freakin break. I have always thought the alleged mother, Alice Hoglan was being less than truthful also. What mother grins and chuckles the very day after her son is tragically killed by terrorists??? Very interesting findings here Phil. No doubt about that. __________________ I am Torgo. I take care of the place while the master is away. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKNTaWElUgA

7 Aug 2010 , 03:42 AM	#9
dutchtreat Privileged Join Date: 5 May 2010 Posts: 121 Threads: 10 Thanked 135 Times in 62 Posts	Hi Phil, excellent research imo and now the net closes because besides the fake cellphone calls from fl 93 now also the false identity is exposed concerning flight 93. the pentagon has already been exposed thru a/ the impossible flight turn before the crash and b/ the funny crash area (reinforced and hardly any people there) the twin towers also have been exposed by you (asbestos, empty and gutted floors etc) hardly any relatives (no one questioned on that day by reporters) on la airport after the twin tower crashes the many many investigations of scams hidden in wtc 7 and "unfortunately" the loss of it when wtc7 went down. the 4 events happened as we know now to start a war to protect oil interest under a false flag. many questions about what happend are solved by this forum. if the existence of Betty Ong in NY can be explained (versus the no passenger theory) than the circle to me is round and then the following question is becoming important : the big question remains : who is the originator or architect of this all ? greetz Ben __________________ We boogied in the kitchen, we boogied in the hall. I got some on my fingers so I wiped it on the wall - Chuck Berry

6 Aug 2010 , 20:41 PM	#2
Bushbasher49 Privileged Join Date: 23 Apr 2010 Posts: 193 Threads: 75 Thanked 310 Times in 124 Posts	is this a grieving mom that just lost her son NO shes smiling and lauging all the why through the video what a fraud and a scam

6 Aug 2010 , 20:59 PM	#4
Jon Simon Moderator Join Date: 4 May 2005 Location: Connecticut Posts: 1,627 Threads: 315 Thanked 366 Times in 152 Posts	That's pretty damning evidence, Phil. Seems there be spooks (intelligence agency assets) in the woodpile at CNN and/or AP. I've always had a huge question mark filed on the Mark Bingham aspect of 9/11. No one I know would call their mom and say, "Mom...this is Mark Bingham." The whole story about taking back the plane with "Let's Roll!" also stunk to high heaven to me. So who is the woman who says she's his mom and she received the call? Seems some very serious and pointed questions need to be directed her way. Jon

6 Aug 2010 , 21:30 PM	#5
Jon Simon Moderator Join Date: 4 May 2005 Location: Connecticut Posts: 1,627 Threads: 315 Thanked 366 Times in 152 Posts	Another interesting thing to do would be to find out the names of the people who worked at CNN or AP the month before 9/11 who's job it was to edit those photos. Who worked in the graphics or editting department. --->There will be our spooks.<--- Jon

7 Aug 2010 , 15:15 PM	#10
Rings of Saturn Academic Join Date: 9 Oct 2007 Posts: 900 Threads: 104 Thanked 221 Times in 114 Posts	Good work...good lord this is huge... Is there anything on Todd Beamer...??? I will not assume that CNN or the AP is in on the job....so, is there anyway of knowing who create those files, loaded them or where they came from. This is now how many different EXIF info dates that are off...from how many sources? Can we assume that someone at the Pent or DOD-- govt agency, gave the media these files for their memorials? This probbaly came from way up....trickled down the line and was eventually fed to us.